You can't tell organic milk by looking at it. What makes it organic is how the cows were kept: their feed and the land it grew on, their access to pasture, their conversion period and how they were treated when sick. All of that follows a written organic standard, checked by an inspection. The rules differ by country, so each section below notes the country it covers.
Thailand has a wrinkle. The general standard, TAS 9000-2021, brings the older separate organic standards into one document, but says its livestock annex will be announced later. So the livestock details here come from the earlier standard for organic livestock, TAS 9000 Part 2 of 2011, issued by the National Bureau of Agricultural Commodity and Food Standards (ACFS).
What the cows eat, and grazing
Thailand. Feed should come from organic farming. During conversion, at least 70 percent of the dry matter fed to ruminants such as cattle has to be organic. If a farm can't source fully organic feed, the standard accepts at least 90 percent organic for ruminants, as long as the certifier approves. Whatever part isn't organic must come from natural plant, animal or mineral sources.
Plant-eating animals must have pasture to graze. There are exceptions, for example in bad weather or in the last stage of gestation.
Roughage, meaning fresh, dried or ensiled forage, has to be at least 60 percent of the daily dry matter. That share can be adjusted by season or stage of lactation, but it can't drop below 50 percent. Ruminants cannot be fed silage alone. Antibiotics, anticoccidial drugs and growth-promoting substances are banned in feed when they're used to speed growth or increase output.
United States. The federal organic rules in 7 CFR part 205 require organic feed. Ruminants must graze for at least 120 days in each calendar year. Over the grazing season, pasture has to supply at least 30 percent of their dry matter intake on average, and the dry feed they're given is capped at an average of 70 percent of what they need. Growth-promoting drugs and hormones are banned, and so are antibiotics in feed.
European Union. According to the European Commission, animals must have access to open air or grazing whenever possible. Farmers must provide 100 percent organic feed, ideally grown on the farm itself or in the same region.
How long conversion takes
Both the land and the animals need time.
Thailand. Land growing feed crops needs 12 months of conversion for annual plants and 18 months for perennials. Cattle, goats and sheep kept for milk go through 90 days of conversion. After that, their milk may be called organic in conversion. Another 6 months have to pass before it can be certified as organic milk.
United States. Dairy animals must have been under continuous organic management for at least 12 months immediately before their milk is sold as organic. A farm that has never converted dairy animals before may convert non-organic animals only once.
EU conversion periods for milk weren't checked for this article, so none are given.
When a cow gets sick
Thailand. A sick or injured animal has to be treated straight away, even if it loses its organic status. Herbs, natural minerals or alternative medicine are tried first. If they fail, a vet can use drugs or antibiotics. The withdrawal period, the waiting time after the last dose, is then twice what the label says, or at least 48 hours if the label gives none. Antibiotics cannot be given routinely as a precaution. An animal that has had drugs or antibiotics more than twice in a year, or once if it is under a year old, can't be sold as organic and goes back into conversion. Any hormone treatment must be supervised by a vet.
United States. An animal that has been given antibiotics cannot be sold as organic. No drugs other than vaccines may be given to an animal that isn't ill, and growth hormones are banned. Producers also may not hold back treatment from a sick animal to keep its organic status.
European Union. The Commission says antibiotics and other veterinary medicines may be used when animals are ill, under strict conditions. Hormones aren't permitted except to treat an individual animal, and growth promoters are forbidden.
In short
- Organic milk is defined by a written standard and an inspection. Nothing about the milk itself shows it.
- Thailand, the United States and the European Union all require organic feed and ban growth promoters.
- In Thailand, roughage is at least 60 percent of daily dry matter, and never below 50 percent even when adjusted.
- The US puts a number on grazing: at least 120 days a year, with pasture giving at least 30 percent of dry matter intake.
- In the US, a cow treated with antibiotics can't supply organic milk. In Thailand, more than two treatments with drugs or antibiotics in a year send her back into conversion.
Common questions
Can you spot organic milk just by looking at it?
You cannot tell organic milk by looking at it because what makes it organic is how the cows were kept.
How long must cattle kept for milk in Thailand convert?
Cattle, goats and sheep kept for milk go through 90 days of conversion, and then another 6 months must pass before the milk is certified as organic.
What happens when a dairy animal gets sick in the United States?
An animal that has been given antibiotics cannot be sold as organic, and producers may not hold back treatment from a sick animal to keep its status.



