A brown egg is brown mainly because of the breed of hen that laid it. A deep orange yolk is orange because of the pigments in what that hen ate. Neither colour is part of the written definitions of how hens are housed, so neither one tells you how the hens were kept.
Shell colour comes from the breed
University of Florida extension explains that shell colour comes from pigments in the outer layer of the shell, and that it is mainly determined by the breed. Commercial breeds lay either white or brown eggs. As a rough rule, breeds with white earlobes lay white eggs and breeds with red earlobes lay brown ones. Individual hens of the same breed still differ, which is why one flock can lay a range of shades.
The same source points out that brown-egg breeds are slightly bigger birds that eat more feed. It is just as clear that shell colour has nothing to do with egg quality, flavour or how the egg behaves in cooking.
The Thai egg standard, TAS 6702-2010, takes the same view. All it asks is that the shell colour be "of the breed characteristic", and that the shell be clean and smooth. No colour is ranked above another. The grades rest on cleanliness, smoothness, the air space and how the egg looks broken out.
Yolk colour comes from what the hen eats
According to University of Florida extension, yolk colour depends on the hen's diet. When she gets plenty of the yellow-orange plant pigments called xanthophylls, they are laid down in the yolk. Utah State University extension names the main pigments as xanthophylls, lutein and zeaxanthin.
The sources give some examples of how that plays out:
- Hens fed mash with yellow corn and alfalfa meal lay eggs with yellow yolks.
- Hens fed white corn, grain sorghum, wheat or barley lay eggs with paler yolks.
- Natural yellow-orange materials, such as marigold petals, may be added to feed to deepen the colour.
- Synthetic pigments such as canthaxanthin can deepen yolk colour too, Utah State University extension adds.
So a deep orange yolk tells you the feed carried a lot of pigment. It doesn't tell you where the pigment came from. That could be the grain the hens ate, plant material mixed into the feed, or a synthetic pigment.
Preferences for yolk colour also differ from country to country, the University of Florida source says. Some consumers like a pale yolk, others want a darker orange, and in most cases the diet is adjusted to produce the colour a particular market asks for. The pigments are fairly stable, and cooking doesn't remove or change them.
On yolks, the Thai standard asks only for a normal and consistent colour.
Why colour isn't a housing label
Rules on farming methods deal with things like space, perches, nests, litter and outdoor access. That is how the European Union defines free range, barn and enriched cage eggs, and it is how the Thai Department of Livestock Development writes its criteria for cage-free layer farms. Neither document mentions shell colour or yolk colour, whether as a requirement or as a test.
So shell colour isn't a measure of quality, and a dark yolk isn't evidence of any particular farming system. If you want to know how the hens were kept, look for a named standard on the carton and a body that inspects against it.
In short
- Breed is the main thing behind shell colour, and white and brown are the usual commercial colours.
- Yolk colour follows the pigments in the hen's feed, whether from yellow corn, marigold petals or a synthetic additive.
- The Thai egg standard asks for a shell colour typical of the breed and a yolk colour that is normal and consistent.
- EU farming-method definitions and the Thai cage-free criteria don't use colour at all.
- To learn how hens were kept, look for a named standard rather than a shade.
Common questions
What makes an eggshell brown?
A brown egg is brown mainly because of the breed of hen that laid it, according to the article.
Why are some egg yolks deep orange?
A deep orange yolk is orange because of the pigments in what that hen ate, as stated in the article.
Does shell colour affect egg quality?
Shell colour has nothing to do with egg quality, flavour or how the egg behaves in cooking, according to the article.
Sources
- University of Florida IFAS Extension, PS24 Egg Quality
- Utah State University Extension, A Farmer's Guide to Egg Quality, Safety, and Flock Health
- Thai Agricultural Standard TAS 6702-2010, Hen Egg (unofficial English translation, ACFS)
- Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/2465 on marketing standards for eggs
- Department of Livestock Development, audit criteria for cage-free layer farms (effective 15 February 2021)



