Small bowls of dried tea leaves and roasted coffee beans on a plain wooden surface.

What organic certification covers in tea and coffee.

Organic rules cover how tea and coffee are grown, handled, processed and recorded. They say nothing about how good the cup tastes.

An organic certificate on tea or coffee is about method. It covers how the crop was grown, how it was handled after picking, how it was processed and packed, and whether the records can prove all of that. It doesn't rate flavour, strength or quality in the cup. A certified tea can taste ordinary, and an uncertified one can taste excellent.

The rules here come from the Thai organic standard, TAS 9000-2021, issued by the National Bureau of Agricultural Commodity and Food Standards (ACFS). It covers the production, processing, labelling and sale of organic produce and products. There is one comparison with the United States, and it is marked as such.

In the field

Tea and coffee grow on bushes and trees that stay in the ground for years. The Thai standard treats them as perennial crops, so the conversion period is at least 18 months before the first organic harvest. For annual crops, it is 12 months before planting.

The count begins on the day the grower starts following the standard and applies to a certifier. It isn't fixed: the certifier can shorten or lengthen it depending on the land's history and risks.

During and after conversion, the grower may use the inputs listed in the standard's annexes. Anything not on those lists can be used only if it passes a separate set of approval criteria.

After picking

Picking is only the start, and from here the main concern is mixing. The standard has a section on handling after harvest. Organic produce must not get mixed with non-organic produce during on-farm steps such as threshing, peeling, cleaning, cooling, cutting, drying and packing.

Packaging and storage must not contaminate the product either. The standard gives examples. Packaging that carries synthetic fungicides, preservatives or fumigants isn't allowed, and neither are reused bags.

A storehouse that also holds other farm products has to keep the organic produce apart, keep each lot identifiable, and clean the space and equipment in a way that has been checked. The operator keeps a written record of the cleaning.

In processing

For processing, the standard calls for mechanical, physical or biological methods, giving examples such as shelling or hulling, milling, fermenting, grinding, pressing and evaporating water. The standard also says:

  • Organic products are not irradiated to control pests, preserve food or kill germs.
  • Extraction may use only water, ethanol, vegetable or animal oils, vinegar, carbon dioxide and nitrogen.
  • Organic, in-conversion and non-organic products must be kept apart by time or by place, and equipment must be cleaned before an organic run.

In the United States, the federal organic rule also lists mechanical and biological methods, including drying, heating and grinding. It bars volatile synthetic solvents, and any synthetic processing aid that isn't on its allowed list.

On the label and in the records

In Thailand, tea or coffee can be labelled "organic" only if the finished product has at least 95% organic ingredients. Solids are counted by weight and liquids by volume, and added water and salt don't count. A flavoured tea, or a blend with herbs, has to meet the same rule across all of its ingredients, so the herbs count too.

At 70% organic ingredients or more, a product may say it is "made with organic ingredients". Below 70%, it can't make organic claims, though the word may still appear in its ingredient list. The label also has to show the name or code of the certifier, and the organic claim must be easy to see and give the approximate percentage of organic ingredients.

Then there are the records. Operators keep records of purchases, handling, processing and stock for at least 5 years, so that any lot can be traced back.

What certification does not cover

The standard sets no rules for taste, aroma or grade. It doesn't decide whether a coffee is a light or dark roast, or how fresh a tea is. Those things are described by the producer and judged in the cup.

In short

  • Organic certification covers growing, handling, processing, packing and records, not flavour or quality in the cup.
  • Under the Thai standard, perennial crops such as tea and coffee need at least 18 months of organic management before the first organic harvest.
  • Mixing organic and non-organic product is controlled at each step, from drying through storage to packing.
  • A Thai "organic" label needs at least 95% organic ingredients, not counting water and salt.
  • Records are kept for at least 5 years, so each lot can be traced.

Common questions

How long must tea be grown organically before the first harvest?

Perennial crops such as tea and coffee need at least 18 months of organic management before the first organic harvest.

What percentage of organic ingredients does a Thai label require?

In Thailand, tea or coffee can be labelled organic only if the finished product has at least 95 percent organic ingredients.

How long do operators need to keep their records?

Operators keep records of purchases, handling, processing and stock for at least 5 years, so that any lot can be traced back.

Sources