Several kinds of fresh vegetables laid out on a table, each with a plain blank paper tag.

Organic, natural, chemical-free and GAP are different things.

The words sound alike but mean different things. Organic and GAP are Thai standards with inspection. The organic standard doesn't define "natural" or "chemical-free".

On a market stall in Thailand you can see "organic", "natural", "chemical-free" and GAP within a few metres of each other, and they don't mean the same thing. Organic and GAP are production standards, and someone inspects farms against them. "Natural" and "chemical-free" are everyday words that the Thai organic standard doesn't define. Each one promises something different, and some promise very little.

Organic

In Thailand, organic farming follows TAS 9000 and is certified. That doesn't mean nothing is ever put on the crop. The standard allows a limited set of substances, those on its own list or ones accepted by the authority or the certification body. It completely rules out synthetic fertilisers and genetically modified organisms.

"Natural" and "chemical-free"

Neither word is defined in TAS 9000 as something you can claim on a label. The standard only mentions natural substances as one group of outside inputs that an organic farm may use in limited cases.

The Thai FDA's labelling notification for packaged food (No. 367, 2014) doesn't help much here either. The word "natural" appears in it only for added colours and flavours, and there is no entry for "chemical-free" at all. What the notification does require is that label text, pictures and marks are not false or misleading in a significant way.

So on their own, these words don't tell you how a crop was grown, or whether anyone checked. Something can be natural in origin and still not be allowed on an organic farm. A "no chemicals" claim on a bag is no different. Unless a standard and a certifier are named next to it, the phrase isn't tied to any checked system.

"Pesticide-safe" vegetables

You'll often see vegetables in Thailand sold as ผักปลอดภัยจากสารพิษ, usually translated into English as "pesticide-safe". The name sounds reassuring, but a Department of Agricultural Extension handout defines it as vegetables from a system that does use chemical pesticides and chemical fertiliser.

The harvest may or may not carry residues. If it does, they have to stay within the limits set by Ministry of Public Health Notification No. 163 of 1995. The same handout keeps this group separate from vegetables grown with no chemical pesticide at all, and separate again from organic vegetables.

GAP and the Q mark

GAP stands for Good Agricultural Practices. In Thailand the standard is TAS 9001, which covers food crops at farm level, such as vegetables, fruit, field crops, spices and herbs. It is about how a farm is run, including how chemicals are handled. It doesn't mean chemicals are never used.

When a GAP farm does use pesticides, it has to follow Department of Agriculture advice or the registered label, and stop using them before harvest for the interval printed on that label. Pesticides banned under the Hazardous Substances Act of 1992 can't be used. The farm records its pesticide use, and where there is evidence or good reason to suspect the advice wasn't followed, the produce is supposed to be tested for residues.

Both GAP and organic standards can be shown with the Q mark, a Thai certification mark for farm products, so the Q alone doesn't tell you which one you're looking at. Check the abbreviation printed with it: "GAP" for good agricultural practice standards, "ORGANIC" for organic ones. The code under the mark identifies the certifying body, the standard and the certificate holder.

Hydroponic

Hydroponics is a way of growing, with the roots in a nutrient solution or in an inert material with nutrients added. It is not a certification. Under TAS 9000 hydroponic growing isn't allowed for organic crops, which have to grow in a soil-based system, so a bag of crisp hydroponic lettuce can't be organic under the Thai standard.

In short

  • Organic is a certified system under TAS 9000, and only a limited list of substances is allowed.
  • The Thai organic standard doesn't define "natural" or "chemical-free". The Thai FDA labelling notification only asks that labels aren't misleading.
  • "Pesticide-safe" vegetables may be grown with chemicals, as long as residues stay within legal limits.
  • GAP (TAS 9001) controls how chemicals are used rather than banning them. Hydroponics is a growing method the Thai organic standard doesn't allow.

Common questions

Can hydroponic lettuce be labeled as organic in Thailand?

Under TAS 9000 hydroponic growing isn't allowed for organic crops, which have to grow in a soil-based system, so hydroponic lettuce cannot be organic under the Thai standard.

Do pesticide-safe vegetables mean no chemicals were used?

A Department of Agricultural Extension handout defines pesticide-safe vegetables as coming from a system that does use chemical pesticides and chemical fertiliser.

What does the Q mark actually indicate on farm products?

Both GAP and organic standards can be shown with the Q mark, but you can check the abbreviation printed with it to tell which standard you are looking at.

Sources