Pick up a few organic packs in Thailand and you may find several different marks on them. They look alike at a glance, but they don't all mean the same thing. Some show that a certification body inspected the farm. One comes from a system where farmers inspect each other. Others belong to the rules of another country or region. For any mark, two questions get you most of the way: who stands behind it, and whose rules does it follow?
The two marks tied to the Thai standard
Thailand's organic standard is TAS 9000, and two marks are linked to it.
Organic Thailand. A Thai university certification institute describes it as the mark for organic production inputs, production sources or products certified by the Department of Agriculture, the Rice Department, the Department of Livestock Development or the Department of Fisheries. These are government departments working as certification bodies, and the mark belongs to them alone.
Q Organic. The Q mark is issued by the National Bureau of Agricultural Commodity and Food Standards (ACFS). According to the same institute, for organic products it goes to certification bodies that meet the international standard ISO/IEC 17065, apart from bodies with legal duties, such as government departments. So the difference is in who did the certifying. The source says the two marks share the same standard.
When farmers check each other: PGS
A participatory guarantee system, or PGS, is certification done by a community instead of an outside body. IFOAM describes it as certification built on the active involvement of stakeholders, on trust, on social networks and on the exchange of knowledge.
The Thai central criteria for PGS name four groups that take part. These are the organic producers themselves, local supporters, consumers or businesses, and an organising body that runs the system.
The people who walk the fields and assess each farm are mainly fellow organic farmers who have been trained for it. Every farm is assessed on an agreed cycle, at least once a year, with the timing set by risk and by the production cycle. Nobody decides alone. Certification is decided at a group meeting, and the organising body keeps the register of certified members and controls how the seal is used.
IFOAM doesn't certify farms
This one causes confusion. IFOAM is an international federation of organic movements, and it does not certify farms at all.
Instead, it sets a global framework for approving organic standards and runs an accreditation programme that checks the certification bodies that do certify farms. A certification body that passes may use the IFOAM Accreditation Seal. That seal tells you something about the certifier. It doesn't mean IFOAM itself inspected a particular farm. IFOAM also runs a recognition programme for PGS initiatives.
USDA Organic and the EU leaf
These two follow the rules of other places, not Thai rules.
USDA Organic belongs to the United States, and its rules are in 7 CFR part 205. The seal may go only on products labelled "100 percent organic" or "organic". The second of those means at least 95 percent organic ingredients, not counting water and salt. You won't see the seal on "made with organic" products. The certifying agent's name appears on the pack. Certified operations are inspected on site every year, and each certifying agent must make unannounced inspections of at least 5 percent of the operations it certifies.
The EU organic leaf is the leaf shape made of twelve white stars on green, and it belongs to the European Union. The European Commission says it is mandatory on pre-packaged organic food produced in the EU, which needs at least 95 percent organic ingredients. Next to the leaf there must be the code of the control body and a note of where the farm ingredients came from. Operators are checked at least once a year.
In short
- Organic Thailand and Q Organic are both tied to TAS 9000. They are issued in different ways, but the standard behind them is the same.
- PGS is certification by a community of farmers and supporters, who inspect one another and decide as a group.
- IFOAM sets the framework for approving standards and accredits certification bodies. It doesn't certify farms.
- USDA Organic and the EU leaf follow United States and European Union rules.
Common questions
How often are farms checked under USDA Organic rules?
Certified operations are inspected on site every year, and each certifying agent must make unannounced inspections of at least five percent of the operations it certifies.
What is the difference between the two marks tied to the Thai standard?
The difference between them is in who did the certifying, although the source notes that the two marks share the same standard.
Does the international federation IFOAM certify individual farms?
IFOAM is an international federation of organic movements, and it does not certify farms at all.
Sources
- Difference between the Organic Thailand and Q Organic marks (Thai university agricultural certification institute, 2014)
- Central criteria for participatory organic certification systems (Thai Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives network)
- IFOAM Accreditation, IFOAM Organics International
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 7 CFR part 205 (USDA National Organic Program)
- European Commission, Organic logo



